Portail e-Justice européen - Case Law
 
 

Chemin de navigation


menu starting dummy link

Page navigation

menu starting dummy link

Case Details

Case Details
National ID C.12.0617.N
État membre Belgique
Common Name link
Decision type Supreme court decision
Decision date 15/05/2014
Juridiction Hof van Cassatie
Objet
Demandeur Multiservice Reizen NV
Défendeur TOTAL Belgium NV
Mots clés consumer, travel

Package Travel Directive, Article 2, 4. Package Travel Directive, Article 2, 5.

A package travel contract, concluded between an entity which is not the actual traveller, and the travel organizer, does not fall under the scope of the rules set out in Directive 90/314 (and the Belgian Act of 16 February 1994 which implements this Directive).
The underlying facts of this case are not mentioned in the judgement, but from the appeal decision it is clear that the plaintiff periodically organized, as a travel organizer, incentive business trips for the defendant. After a certain time, a discussion arose between the parties and they ended up before court for unpaid invoices. Whereas defendant invoked the protection provided by the provisions set out in Directive 90/314 (implemented into Belgian law in the Act of 16 February 1994), the plaintiff stated that this Directive/Act cannot be applied as the contract was concluded between two corporate entities, and not between a traveller (natural person) and the travel organizer.
Does a package travel contract, concluded between an entity which is not the actual traveller, and the travel organizer, fall under the scope of the rules set out in Directive 90/314 (and the Belgian Act of 16 February 1994 which implements this Directive)?
The Belgian Supreme Court states that only the actual travellers (natural persons) can be considered "traveller" in the sense of the Directive 90/314 and the Belgian implementation Act of 16 February 1994. As a result of this, the Supreme Court concludes that the contract concluded on behalf of the actual travellers, by a corporate entity, does not fall under the scope of the Directive 90/314.
Full Text: Full Text
Member State National ID Common Name Directive Articles Decision Date
Belgique link link Package Travel Directive, Article 2, 4. Package Travel Directive, Article 2, 5. 08/05/2012

No results available

The Supreme Court overruled the judgement of the appellate court which had decided that the Directive 90/314 does apply to such contracts.