On 19 April 2010, the plaintiff, a pay-tv supplier, reported the possible unfairness of several advertisements which its competitor, the defendant, broadcasted between January and April 2010, concerning an offer advertised as “Calcio, cinema, serie TV e Disney Channel a 19,90 EURO al mese” ("Football, movies, television series and Disney Channel for 19,90 EURO per month").
On 9 June 2010, the Italian Competition Authority decided to start investigation proceedings against RTI S.p.A. Investigations mainly related to the alleged omission of defendant to provide sufficient information on: (i) the period of the advertised monthly price; (ii) possible charges to the consumers; (iii) the duration of the contract and the nature and terms of the subscription; (iv) the costs charged to the consumer in the event of withdrawal; (v) the period of the offer; (vi) the cost of the phone call to the customer care.
The defendant stated that, due to the limitations of the communication media it used (radio and television advertisements), it was limited in its possibility to offer full information to the consumers. In each advertisement the defendant was referred to the full text of the conditions of the offer, which was consultable on the defendant's website and in leaflets available in each point of sale of the defendant.