According to the court, the information provided by plaintiff on its website was not misleading. The average consumer, who is reasonably well-informed and reasonably observant and circumspect, could easily discover that it was not only an online test. Although the attention of consumers was mainly directed towards the test, the banners made sufficiently clear that there was a paid subscription service involved. Hence, according to the court, there was no misleading commercial practice.
As to the failure of the plaintiff to adhere to the codes of conduct which it had subscribed to, the court states that in case a trader explicitly declares that it is bound to rules of self-regulation, the average consumer should be able to assume that a trader actually adheres to these rules. Failure to comply with these rules, important or not, does in itself affect the transactional decisions to be made by consumers in respect of the services offered. Therefore, obligations under the SMS Service Provision Code of Conduct must be strictly adhered to.
As to the use of the suitable advice, the court ruled that providing information about a main characteristic of the service by way of a link to "suitable devices" is insufficient to make consumers aware of this. There was enough space on the plaintiff's website to provide this information in a more direct and transparent manner.
Finally, the court considered the question in relation to providing information about the main characteristics of the service only by way of making reference to a website during a television commercial. The court held that the information involved did not concern information that speaks for itself, but concerned the main characteristics of the services. Therefore, this information was not allowed to remain unmentioned. The reference made to the website was only visible for a short time on television. This caused the way in which the information was provided to be inappropriate and unclear, which constitutes a misleading omission.
URL: http://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/inziendocument?id=ECLI:NL:RBROT:2012:BW3358&keyword=ECLI%3aNL%3aRBROT%3a2012%3aBW3358
Integrale tekst: Integrale tekst